Ugh. It happened again! Lis and I went for a seat belt safety class last night, which had some really great information. We learned all about the safety labels, expiry dates, weight and height restrictions, installation techniques and more. Did you know, for example, that kids are now required by law to stay in booster seats until they're 4'9"? For a lot of kids, that can be as old as 12 or even more. I'm so happy we signed up for this, because we're now feeling extra secure (haha) in our car safety knowledge.

What we didn't sign up for, however, was the lesson in gender discipline that came along with the class. There was a lot of, how shall I say it, peripheral instruction going on about who we were supposed to be as men and women. Apparently all men install car seats, and they consider it a point of pride, but they always get it wrong and should find this very humiliating. It's their role, after all, to do everything requiring technical ability, and to screw it up because they're really just a bunch of barely functioning brutes. Women, on the other hand, are a bunch of harried, overemotional hens whose only purpose in life is to peck at their husbands and worry constantly about all of the things that their bumbling male counterparts are too stupid and stubborn to realize. There was a real undercurrent of hate in the the instructor's thought, and I found it infuriating. She was relentless. It was a peculiar version of hell on earth.

I felt, in fact, like I was stuck one of those horrific Leon's furniture commercials. You know, the ones where the wife fakes a headache until her husband buys her a fridge? This is what adult relationships look like without an awareness of egalitarian politics. This is an all out war of the sexes where nobody knows what they're fighting for, they just know they want the other one dead. We will claw and kill and maim just to get the upper hand. We will ridicule and humiliate and belittle any way we can think of, because the thing that matters is not the relationship but the person who has the power. Be forewarned, love is an illusion, and anyone stupid enough to believe in its power will be culturally scorned and socially ostracized.

To be honest, I don't have any problem with other people playing out their relationships however they want, but to impose such a worldview on others is both oppressive and offensive. It also has no place in a car seat belt safety course. Relationships should be configured however the couple sees fit, and this can include women or men occupying whatever roles they like (technical, emotional, intellectual, spiritual, fashionable, physical). There may be tendencies, but there are no inherently "masculine" or "feminine" traits; binding activities to bodies is a dangerous practice, in no small part because it distracts us from learning about the things that matter.
Iris
12/11/2012 11:29:09 pm

I am struck by the depth of your observations in this post and the last one. I am thrown back to the early 1970's when many of us, especially consciously-raised women were contemplating the restrictions of socially imposed gender norms. We were challenging the notion that all "normal" (not abnormal) women had specific characteristics and all "normal" men had other, usually opposing, characteristics. The new notion that well functioning adults could perform and enjoy activities and tasks usually identified with the opposite gender was an important push from the feminists. At that time, in the 1970's, Dr. Sandra Bem, an American social psychologist studied and wrote about the concept of psychologically androgenous women who happily fixed things around the house or worked in nontraditional jobs while enjoying motherhood and dressing in skirts. She found that androgenous women and men are more flexible, mentally healthy and perceive their circumstances as controllable by themselves versus luck or fate. She said what you said, that tight gender roles are restrictive for both men and women. Later she developed the idea of gender schema theory which suggests that gender roles colour how people see the world. Androgenous perspectives widen our view of the world.

I was lucky: I had a feminist mother (not so labeled in the 50's). When, at age 5, I came home from the playground unhappy because a little boy said I should not be there to play because I was wearing a skirt, my mother said, "Iris, you can do anything in the world that you want, and you can do it in a skirt!" And I did!
.

Reply
Lis
12/12/2012 12:52:42 am

Loved this comment; thank you for it. (you are an amazing role model!)

Reply
12/17/2012 02:44:55 am

Loved it too! Your mom sounds like a remarkable woman (very similar to Lis's mother, in that regard!) That's also very interesting about Sandra Bem's theories. I'm sure she influences my thinking via all of the gender theory profs I've had classes with over the years.

Reply
Heather
12/12/2012 06:34:58 am

I look forward to more of your posts about gender binaries in the coming years, R! It only continues, of course. My particular interest in theories of children's gender is in children's literature marketing. While the publishing juggernaut of Harry Potter has done a great job of taking us away from the "Adventures for boys" and "Princesses for girls" paradigm (and there is a great wealth of authors who-- more so than Rowling-- work hard to break down these barriers), my 8-year-old niece recently face-timed me because she was very angry that her school book fair (Scholastic, I think) had a table for boys and a table for girls. She was horrified that Diary of a Wimpy Kid and other books that she loves were classified as "boys' books." She knew that trend existed, of course, but the physical use of space-- placing the books on separate tables with distinct signs-- made her especially uncomfortable and upset. That's one budding feminist at least!

Reply
12/20/2012 07:37:27 am

Great observations, Ryan.

Jason and I faced similarly eye-opening experiences in our daddies and papas to be course. Try taking one gender out of the equation and see how people's head's explode. Questions like, "but who's more the man and who's more the woman?" were suddenly commonplace.
I can't imagine what we have to look forward to once we actually get going on parenting!

Reply



Leave a Reply.